Indeed, since the beginning of 2009 shares in Whitbread have gained 410% excluding dividends, while shares in ABFhave added 305% excluding dividends. Over the same period, the FTSE 100 has gained only 70% excluding dividends.
However, despite the impressive returns achieved by both of these companies over the past eight-and-a-half years, it could be time for investors to consider selling up and moving on to more attractive opportunities elsewhere.
For the financial year ending 30 September, City analysts are expecting ABFto report a pre-tax profit of 1.3bn and earnings per share of 122p.
Based on these figures shares in the Primark ownerare trading a forward P/E multiple of 24.1, which looks expensive. Year-on-year the companys earnings per share are expected to grow by 15% for this fiscal year and then by 9% for the year after. A mid-teens earnings multiple would be more suitable for this moderate growth rate.
Itsgrowth over the past few years has mainly been fuelled by the expansion of the off-price retail brand Primark. While the chainsgrowth has helped the overall group power ahead in recent years, analysts widely believe consumers are set to rein-in spending over the next year as rising inflation puts pressure on spending. This trend might slow downPrimarks growth story.
A high earnings multiple does not leave much room for manoeuvre if the company fails to hit City targets for growth. Whats more, the dividend yield leaves a lot to be desired. At the time of writing the shares support a yield of just 1.2%. Still, theres plenty of room for payout growth with the dividend covered almost three times by earnings per share, although analysts do not see a hike on the horizon any time soon.
Coffee shop saturation
Like ABF, Whitbread also looks expensive compared to the companys projected growth rate. Over the past five years, itsgrowth has exploded as the company has aggressively rolled out its Costa coffee brand and revamped its hotels business Premier Inn. But growth is now slowing thanks to a number of factors.
The firms results for the 52 weeks to 2 March showed overall group revenue rising 8.2% to 3.1bnbut most of this growth came from international expansion. Like-for-like sales growth at Premier Inn was 1.5%, down from 4.2% in the year-ago period, and Costa like-for-like growth was 2%, down from 2.9%. The groups restaurant business saw sales decline 0.3% on a like-for -like basis.
For the fiscal year ending February 2018, City analysts are expecting Whitbread to report earnings per share growth of 4%, a disappointing figure considering that for the last five years the company has reported an average annual income growth rate of around 14.4%. Nonetheless, even though growth is slowing and competition is intensifying, the shares trade at a forward P/E of 16.5 and yield 2.4%.
It might not be worth paying such a substantial premium for a company that looks like its best growth days are behind it.
Time to give up?
If you’re ready to give up on Whitbread and ABF, there are plenty of businesses out there which look to be strong growth champions. And to help you find these companies, we’ve put together this free report.
The report is a collection of Foolish wisdom, which should help you improve your investment returns and avoid needlessly losing too many more profits. The best part is that it’s completely free and comes with no further obligation. So to help improve your investment process today, click here to download. What have you got to lose?