In this article Ill take a look at each stock and ask whether now is the time to buy.
On the face of it, theres no logical reason to buy or own shares in Tesco. The dividend has been cancelled, the shares trade on nearly 40 times 2015/16 forecast earnings and the firms 10bn net debt is far too high.Tescos asset backing is shaky, too. The current 188p share price is 2.5 times the firms 75p per share book price.
Given all of this, why havent Tesco shares fallen further, perhaps to as low as 100p?
Rightly or wrongly, the market is pricing in an eventual recovery for Tesco. It remains the UKs largest supermarket, with a market share of around 28%. Total revenue this year is expected to be around 55bn.The City believes that Tesco can turnaround its business, and I tend to agree. Over a 3 to 5 year timescale, I expect Tesco to make a decent recovery.
However, I wouldnt buy Tesco shares today, as I believe a lot of this potential recovery is already in the price.
Like Tesco, Vodafone appears to be priced to reflect the markets expectation that profits will eventually recover. The big difference is that Vodafone offers an attractive 5.3% dividend yield and has a much stronger balance sheet.
Vodafones board has committed to maintain this dividend, but its not completely safe. Earnings are only expected to cover half the cost of the dividend between now and 2017, leaving Vodafone reliant on its reserves to fund the payout.
Vodafones profits should rise as spending on the Project Spring 3G/4G network upgrade programme tails off. Theres also evidence that European markets are starting to recover. The other possibility is that Vodafone will make a big acquisition to boost earnings.
Im happy to hold, but if theres no sign of progress next year, I may start to worry.
BAE Systems ought to be a fairly safe share to hold. The firms biggest customers are governments in the UK, USA and Middle East. There doesnt seem to be much chance that any of these countries will stop spending money on defence.
Its not necessarily that simple though. BAEs smaller UK peers, Chemring and Meggitt, have both fallen by around 20% over the last month after issuing profit warnings.The problem is that earnings visibility seems to be increasingly poor, and this could affect BAE.
Although the groups order backlog of 37.3bn ought to be reassuring, short term earnings are less certain. BAEs Australian ship-building business has run out of orders, and the order pipeline for Typhoon jets is also causing uncertainty.The firm warned earlier this year that earnings forecasts did depend on some anticipated naval and aircraft orders. I wouldnt be surprised to see earnings slip a little this year.
BAE shares have fallen by 10% over the last six months. They now trade on 11.8 times forecast earnings, with a prospective yield of 4.7%. That seems fairly reasonable, but in my view, the shares arent quite the bargain they were a few years ago.
Indeed, many investors are finding that owning shares in blue chip names like Tesco, Vodafone Group and BAE is riskier than they expected it to be.
To help you avoid future Tesco-style losses and maximise the returns from your investment portfolio, the Motley Fool’s top analysts have produced “5 Shares To Retire On“.
This exclusive report contains details of five hand-picked companies the Fool’s experts believe could outperform the wider market and provide reliable dividend growth.
“5 Shares …” is completely FREE and carries no obligation. I’d urge you to download this report immediately.
To receive your copy today, click here now.
Roland Head owns shares of Tesco, BAE Systems and Vodafone Group. The Motley Fool UK has no position in any of the shares mentioned. We Fools don’t all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors.