At first sight theres little in common between struggling supermarket chain Tesco (LSE: TSCO) and these two global miners, Rio Tinto (LSE: RIO) (NYSE: RIO.US) and its would-be suitor Glencore (LSE: GLEN) though both sectors are facing difficult markets, and Ivan Glasenbergs success in building Glencore bears some resemblance to Terry Leahy at Tesco.
Tescos latest troubles have arisen from poor corporate governance. The 250m profit-forecast overstatement was made in the interval when Tesco didnt have a finance director. According to a report in the Sunday Times two weeks ago, the former FD Laurie McIlwee and former CEO Philip Clarke hadnt been on speaking terms for two months before McIliwees departure: thats a situation no chairman should tolerate.
No FD, no comment
Heres something that may surprise you. Glencore doesnt even have a finance director. The then-FD stood down from the board when Glencore acquired Xstrata in 2013, continuing to be employed as Chief Financial Officer. That matters as 1) he doesnt have fiduciary responsibilities to shareholders like a director does, 2) hes clearly subordinate to the CEO, 3) its much easier for an employee to say I was just following orders than a finance director who would have to resign if his professional advice wasnt followed.
Whats more, unlike most FTSE 100 companies, Glencore doesnt have a former senior FD on its board. Ivan Glasenberg, the CEO and sole executive director, is the only former accountant. The three members of the audit committee are investment bankers. They undoubtedly have, as Glencore says, recent and relevant financial experience and competence in accounting, but probably not the same mentality as is forged by the grunt and grind of auditing. With former BP CEO Tony Hayward as chairman, the board is more entrepreneurial than focused on checks and balances.
Mr Glasenberg has built Glencore into a massive powerhouse since taking the reins in 2002, though the shares are down 37% since its 2011 flotation. But Tesco demonstrates how the pressure to perform can be dangerous without a culture of checks and balances in the background.
Rio similarly grew fast under a hard-driving CEO during minings boom years, but that story turned sour with $14bn worth of write-offs arising from over-ambitious acquisitions. A new CEO has successfully steered Rio in a different direction, concentrating on shareholder returns and turning Rio into one of the top two most-efficient miners. The current depression in iron ore prices almost certainly means that if shareholders succumb to any further advances from Glencore, then they will be giving away the upside to Glencores shareholders.
Quality of management is one of the factors that the Motley Fool’s flagship Championship PRO Service looks at before recommending companies. This exclusive service provides ideas on investments in a wide range of styles, including core investments in business that generate superior returns on capital, small-cap growth stocks and special situations. In the time that Glencore’s shares have lost 37%, the service’s real-money portfolio has grown by 37.1% — compared to the FTSE all-share total return of just 27.8%.
The service has just re-opened for membership and, to help you evaluate the benefits of membership, for a limited period you can get four small-cap ideas, all completely free and without obligation. Just click here to download the first free report.
Tony Reading owns shares in Rio Tinto and Tesco. The Motley Fool UK owns shares of Tesco. We Fools don’t all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors.